Predictions, and results

Jim Cramer, who has been quite consistent in his condemnation of the Fed since this wholly unnecessary financial unpleasantness surfaced last summer, says that panic will be in charge on Tuesday:

There was a time when there wasn’t so much to fear. Had the Fed cut rates rapid-fire by 200 to 300 basis points last summer, we could have had refinancing off the short rates for home equity lines of credit and hurting first mortgages. That would have at least given us time to work out of this jam. Just a gigantic short-term cut in the discount rate could have done a world of good. But we got nothing except “The fundamentals are sound.”

Now it is too little and too late. I figure the Fed tomorrow will announce some other complicated scientific way to screw things up, just like it did with the bogus SIV plan and the ridiculously small TAF auctions. All of that stuff is just the kind of small-time, small-think Fed stuff that we have come to expect from this oblivious Fed chairman. Worse is the ludicrous nature of the government’s planned tax rebates, which will do absolutely nothing to get things going at all. Nothing.

Cramers’ opinion of Bernanke has come to be shared by many observers. The Princeton professor was said to be a great historian of the Depression, but perhaps, some say, that only meant that he was a student of how we got into the Depression, since his corrective measures, like those of 75 years ago, appear to be too little too late. The markets have said that the 25 basis point cut on December 11 was an indication that the Fed was out of touch with the reality of the markets.

We live in the internet age. If interest rates should be cut 200 basis points, then the Fed should cut by that amount, in one lump or two, and it should do it promptly. Instead, at least to date, we have witnessed a Fed that seems to observe a 19th century model of information flow — that change has to dribble out incrementally by 25-50 basis points over a couple of years, apparently because information needs months to disseminate and industries and individuals need to process the information. (As economist and Fed observer Irving Fisher said early in the last century “Turn the wheel slightly, and if that is not enough, you turn it some more.”) Rubbish. That’s a formula for being the last car on the roller coaster — going along for a scary ride downhill, until things begin to turn up again eventually.

mm.gif

As it turned out, the Fed cut rates 75bp in response to the global market panic and and the Dow opened down about 500 points, then recovered in intra-day trading, and closed down 128.

4 Responses to “Predictions, and results”

  1. gs Says:

    At the moment, European markets are rebounding. The S&P 500 is around 1310 (down about 1%); the futures were down over 5% overnight.

  2. Canucklehead Says:

    I can accept Cramer’s point of view if we knew the full extent of the sub-prime impact on the banking institutions. Since we don’t, and the banks have clearly been leaking out information in dribs and drabs, the Fed needs to march in step with the ethics of the banking industry.

    We aren’t playing Parker Brothers’ “Monopoly” here. The banking system needs to learn to support themselves and not rely on a Greenspan “Get Out of Jail Free” card.

    I don’t think a large rate cut in December would have been good for the market. A big cut would have generated blog discussions about “How Bad is It Really? Look at What the Fed Did!”. You would have had panic.

    Jim Cramer can be a Monday Morning Quarterback on this. He is entitled to his opinion. Maybe he should run for office? Maybe he shouldn’t…

  3. gs Says:

    Three weeks ago, I took uneasy refuge in the fact that

    …corporate insiders continue to buy like drunken sailors.

    The most recent tracking newsletter reports a change: now insiders are buying like a drunken sailor who just won the lottery.

  4. MarkD Says:

    What we lack, as noted, is data. Some number of loans are in trouble. That is the maximum this damage can amount to, and the assets still exist and are worth something. At least this isn’t like an investment in an internet startup that fizzled to zero. Lots of people will be hurt, but they are people who bought a house they couldn’t afford with a loan they couldn’t repay. Freedom includes the freedom to make mistakes.

    I’m on the side of the insiders. My 401K allocations and future investments remain the same. Might 2008 be a bad year? Yes, it sure looks that way. I’ve a long way to go till retirement, so that’s my horizon.

Leave a Reply