Throwing out the baby, keeping the bathwater
GE is shutting its last light bulb factory in the US. The jobs destroyed in the US are now in China. The new product is harder to use (e.g., outside) and often gives off a dim, unpleasant light. And some more bad things, but first read this. WaPo:
The last major GE factory making ordinary incandescent light bulbs in the United States is closing this month, marking a small, sad exit for a product and company that can trace their roots to Thomas Alva Edison’s innovations in the 1870s. The remaining 200 workers at the plant here will lose their jobs…
Rather than setting off a boom in the U.S. manufacture of replacement lights, the leading replacement lights are compact fluorescents, or CFLs, which are made almost entirely overseas, mostly in China. Consisting of glass tubes twisted into a spiral, they require more hand labor, which is cheaper there. So though they were first developed by American engineers in the 1970s, none of the major brands make CFLs in the United States.
“Everybody’s jumping on the green bandwagon,” said Pat Doyle, 54, who has worked at the plant for 26 years. But “we’ve been sold out. First sold out by the government. Then sold out by GE.”…The company developed a plan to see what it would take to retrofit a plant that makes traditional incandescents into one that makes CFLs. Even with a $40 million investment and automation, the disparity in wages and other factors made it uneconomical. The new plant’s CFLs would have cost about 50 percent more than those from China, GE officials said…
In announcing the plant closure here, GE said in a news release that “a variety of energy regulations,” including those in the United States, “will soon make the familiar lighting products produced at the Winchester Plant obsolete.”
Here are some other excellent product features, as highlighted by GE itself:
CFLs, like many electrical or electronic products, can sometimes fail in a way where one of the electrical components or plastic materials will briefly produce a very irritating odor and possibly some smoke…the easiest way to eliminate any odor is to follow the same approach that one would use to eliminate any other unpleasant odor or smell. Briefly leave the immediate area if it is very irritating. Next, after waiting 10 or 15 minutes, air out the room…
Like paint, batteries, thermostats, and other hazardous household items, CFLs should be disposed of properly. Do not throw CFLs away in your household garbage…If your waste agency incinerates its garbage, you should search a wider geographic area for proper disposal options. Never send a CFL or other mercury containing product to an incinerator
So let’s see. A simple, very effective and cheap product is replaced by an inferior, more costly product, produced in a fashion that eliminates American jobs, and that creates completely unnecessary bad environmental consequences.. And all so some nincompoops can feel good about themselves. What’s a good name for a scam of this nature? Ah yes, the “green economy.”

September 10th, 2010 at 2:08 am
What’s really sick about this is that the LED will supplant the CFL within afew years and we will actually have an improvement to the incandescent light. In the meantime, we will release tons of mercury and other toxins into our waste stream and the environment.
These are the same folks who brought you furnaces with no pilot light that rusted out when the heat exchangers corroded and the two flush toilets that didn’t save water. I expected no difference and am stocking up on incandescents while I can still get them.
September 10th, 2010 at 3:47 pm
My big problem with the CFL lights is that there is apparently no quality control in the manufacturing process. Mine have suffered a failure rate in excess of 20% during the first week of operation. If they make it through the first week they seem to be OK, but a week lifespan for a bulb that is supposed to last years isn’t good.
September 11th, 2010 at 5:07 pm
The lightbulb fiasco — signed into law by GWB, don’t forget — is just more proof that the American people are spineless worthless sheep who will do anything that their government tells them. Our civilization no longer has any vigor. We are dying, rapidly.